An SEO audit is a structured review of your website and your online presence that finds out why you are, or are not, showing up when people search for what you do. A good one today looks at three places, not one: the Google map pack, the organic blue links, and AI search, meaning Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode plus assistants like ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity.
Here is the thing. If you typed “SEO audit” into Google, there is probably a reason. Your phone isn’t ringing the way it should. When you search for your own service and your own town, your competitors come up and you don’t. Or you asked ChatGPT who the best plumber, roofer, dentist, or landscaper in your area is, and it recommended somebody else. You’re not here because you’re curious about SEO. You’re here because something isn’t working, and you want to know what.
We can show you. Local AI SEO and GEO have gotten complicated, and we’ll explain why throughout this guide. If you’d rather skip the reading and just see what’s going on with your own site, reach out for a free, no-strings screen-share review. We’ll pull up your Google Search Console, SE Ranking, and SE Visible data with you on the call, show you where you stand in the map pack, Google, and AI search, and point out the low-hanging fruit you could fix right away. No sales deck. Just a conversation about your website, led by a real strategist with years of experience, not a tool that hands you a score. We use software, including AI tools, to pull the data together fast. A person still makes sense of it with you.
Why you’re probably reading this
Most local service businesses lose jobs for one reason: their competitors show up first. Not because the competitor is better. Because the competitor is more visible in the three places your customers actually look.
The first place is the map pack, the three businesses Google shows on the map when someone searches “HVAC repair Fort Collins” or “dentist near me.” If you’re not in the top three on the map, you’re not getting that call.
The second place is the organic results, the blue links underneath. Your service pages, your location pages, your reviews, your guides. This is where someone who wants to compare a few options ends up.
The third place is new, and it’s the one most SEO audits skip entirely: AI search. Google’s AI Overviews now sit at the top of many searches, AI Mode answers in full sentences, and more and more people simply ask ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, or Perplexity who they should hire. At Boulder SEO Marketing, at least half of our own new leads now come from AI search. We know because we ask every lead how they found us.
We talk to owners in this exact spot every week, and we’ve been there ourselves. By 2021 we had gotten so busy with client work that we stopped optimizing our own website. Then a Google core update hit. We lost most of our organic traffic, roughly 80 percent by my count, leads dried up, and sales followed. It was devastating, and it was exactly what our clients go through.
We panicked for about a day. Then we went back to basics, page by page and keyword by keyword: find the pages already sitting on page two or three, sharpen them, move them to page one. That method became Micro SEO Strategies℠, and it started with an honest audit of our own site. Today, when someone searches “SEO agency Boulder,” we’re at the top of the map pack and hold multiple spots on page one of the blue links, and AI search recommends us for the same question and the ways people rephrase it, like “best SEO agency in Boulder, Colorado.” We are exactly who we work with, and we do for our clients what we did for ourselves.
Seo Agency Boulder Google Results
What is an SEO audit?
An SEO audit is a diagnosis. It checks whether search engines can find, read, and trust your website, whether your pages match what your customers actually search for, and whether your business shows up where it needs to. The output is a prioritized list of what’s broken, what’s close to working, and what to fix first.
What an SEO audit is not: a 40-page PDF of red and green checkmarks from an automated tool. Those tools have their place, and we use several of them. But a tool can tell you that 212 images are missing alt text. It can’t tell you that your site was never indexed, that your best service page is sitting at position 14 for a term worth thousands of dollars a month, or that ChatGPT has never heard of you. Those are the findings that change whether your phone rings.
An audit is also not a strategy. A keyword list isn’t a plan. The audit tells you where you are; the strategy decides what to do about it, in what order, and why.
You need an SEO audit when something has changed or something never worked in the first place. Traffic dropped and you don’t know why. You launched a new site and the phone went quiet. You’ve been through an agency or two and you’re not sure what they actually did. You rank fine on the map but nowhere in the blue links, or the other way around. Or you’ve simply never checked whether AI search knows your business exists.
What does an SEO audit cover today?
A complete SEO audit covers six areas: technical SEO, content, on-page SEO, off-page SEO, your Google Business Profile, and AI search visibility. The first four are the classics, and every audit tool on the market checks them. The last two are where most audits stop short, and they’re the two that matter most for a local service business.
| Area | What a classic SEO audit checks | What a local AI SEO audit adds |
|---|---|---|
| Technical SEO | Crawl errors, indexing, site structure, mobile, speed | Whether the site is indexed at all, whether AI crawlers can read it, schema that names your business, services, and author |
| Content | Keyword use, freshness, duplicate pages | Whether pages answer the questions customers ask in Google and in AI, whether there is one strong page per topic instead of fifty thin ones |
| On-page SEO | Title tags, meta descriptions, headings, internal links | Titles written for clicks when an AI Overview sits above you, headings that match how people phrase questions |
| Off-page SEO | Backlinks, mentions, social signals | Brand consistency across every listing, YouTube and LinkedIn presence, the places AI pulls answers from |
| Google Business Profile | Usually not covered | Categories, services, photos, posts, reviews and replies, citations, map pack position for your top searches |
| AI search visibility | Not covered | Whether ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode mention you, cite you, or recommend a competitor instead |
Google’s own guidance makes the point for us. In its guide to optimizing for generative AI features, Google says that optimizing for AI Overviews and AI Mode is still SEO, built on the same ranking and quality systems, and that AI features run related follow-up searches behind the scenes to build an answer. So a modern audit doesn’t replace the classics. It checks the classics and then asks whether all of that work is reaching the places your customers now look.
Components of an SEO audit
1. Indexing and crawlability
Indexing and crawlability determine whether Google can find your pages and store them in its index at all. Nothing else on this list matters until this is settled, which is why it’s the first thing we check on every first call.
One of the most eye-opening moments we see: we search Google for a prospect’s site, and it isn’t there. It happens with do-it-yourself builders like Wix and GoDaddy. It’s even more common on WordPress sites, where a developer leaves the “discourage search engines from indexing this site” box checked after launch. The owner thinks the site is being found. Google can’t see it. A technical SEO audit catches this in about thirty seconds, and it’s the cheapest fix with the biggest payoff you’ll ever make.
2. Rankability and low-hanging fruit
Rankability is where your pages actually stand for the searches that bring in work, and how far they are from the spots that get clicked. The most valuable part of any SEO audit report is a short list of pages sitting at positions 11 to 30 for terms with real volume and real buying intent. Those pages are already in the game. They need to be sharpened, not rebuilt.
This is the heart of how we work. A page on page two of Google is a page Google already trusts a little. Improve the title, answer the question better, add the proof, fix the internal links, and it moves. How fast it moves depends heavily on who the author is, which we’ll get to in component eight. Either way, it beats starting from zero.
3. Page speed, honestly
Page speed matters, and a slow site frustrates visitors and makes them leave. We check it in every audit. We’ll also be honest: speed is rarely the reason your phone isn’t ringing. We’ve audited plenty of fast sites that nobody could find and slow sites that ranked beautifully. Run your site through Google’s free PageSpeed Insights tool, fix the obvious problems with a simple, proven plugin, don’t chase perfect scores, and don’t let anyone sell you a speed overhaul before they’ve checked whether your site is indexed.
4. User experience and conversion
User experience in an SEO audit means one practical question: when someone lands on your site, can they figure out what you do and how to call you in under five seconds? On one plumbing account, rankings were recovering nicely but leads weren’t coming in. Our team dug into Google Analytics and found about 300 organic visits in a month producing only nine calls or form fills. The call-to-action disappeared as visitors scrolled, nothing stayed sticky, and most people landed on the homepage instead of a service page. The good news was that people were finding them. The leak was after they arrived, and that’s fixable. We now check for the right message above the fold, a visible call-to-action, a sticky call bar on mobile, and whether traffic is landing on the right pages.
One more thing a website audit can’t fix: if the phones aren’t answered, no SEO fixes that. We bring it up anyway, because we’d rather you hear it from us before you spend a dollar.
5. Google Business Profile and the map pack
A Google Business Profile audit checks the one asset that decides whether you’re in the map pack: your profile. Primary and secondary categories, services listed, photos, weekly posts, review count and how you reply to reviews, and whether your name, address, and phone number match everywhere else on the web. It also checks where you actually rank on the map for your top five searches, from your own neighborhood and from across town, because the map pack weights physical distance heavily.
We’ve watched businesses with strong profiles rank in the map pack while their website was invisible, and the reverse. One of our clients, a LASIK provider, had a strong map pack presence for “LASIK Denver” but the organic blue links underneath were underperforming; the fix was on the website, not the profile. You can read how it played out in the 20/20 Institute case study. The two systems are related but they are not the same thing, and an audit has to look at both.
6. AI search visibility
An AI visibility audit answers a simple question: when someone asks an AI assistant who to hire for what you do, in your area, does it name you? We run the question in ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity, and in Google’s AI Mode, and we look at what Google’s AI Overviews show for your most important searches. Then we look at why. AI answers are built from what’s already on your website and across the web, so if your service pages are thin, your business is described five different ways across five directories, and you have no presence on YouTube or LinkedIn, there’s nothing for the AI to cite.
Search Console Generative AI Report
Two things worth knowing. Google Search Console now has a generative AI performance report that shows how often your pages appear inside AI Overviews and AI Mode. It shows impressions only, no clicks and no queries, so it tells you whether you’re in the room, not whether anyone walked over. For the rest, tools like SE Ranking’s SE Visible track whether ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and Google AI Mode mention you across the prompts your customers use.
We also set up an llms.txt file for every client at onboarding. Google says it doesn’t use the file, and we take them at their word. Other AI systems may, and it costs nothing to have. We’d never tell you that skipping it will hurt your site. We’d also rather be ready if that changes.
7. Schema and backlinks
A schema audit checks whether your pages carry structured data that tells Google and AI systems exactly what your business is, where it is, what it offers, and who wrote the content. Two free, official tools do this: Google’s Rich Results Test tells you whether a page qualifies for Google’s rich results, and the Schema Markup Validator from schema.org checks whether the markup itself is valid. Most local service sites we audit have either no schema or a plugin’s default that names nothing specific. That’s a gap, and it’s a quick one to close.
A backlink audit looks at who links to you, whether those links help or hurt, and how your link profile compares to the competitors above you. We run this through SE Ranking’s backlink audit and share the report. We don’t buy links and we don’t sell link-building schemes; we look for the real gaps, like a local newspaper that covered you without linking, or a directory listing that’s wrong.
8. Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness
This is the component most audits leave out, and it’s the one that decides how fast everything else works. You can do every item on this list to a T: technical, on-page, off-page, content, social, the full strategy. If the person associated with your content has no track record Google and AI can verify, it will still take a long time. Google’s own guidance on helpful content asks who created the content, how, and why, and it tells raters to weigh experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness, with trust counting most.
We see this on our own site. Content published under my name, with nearly 30 years in search behind it, often reaches page one within about a day or two. The same page under an unknown byline can take months. That isn’t a trick; it’s the accumulated trust of a real person with a real footprint across the web. So an honest audit asks: who is the face of this business, what can be found about them, and what would it take to build that footprint? It doesn’t happen overnight. It’s part of the strategy from day one, and good things take a little time.
How we do an SEO audit
Our SEO audit process starts with your real data and ends with a conversation, not a document. Here is what happens, in order.
- Access. We ask for access to your Google Search Console and Google Analytics. If you don’t have Search Console set up, that’s finding number one, and we’ll walk you through it.
- The data pull. We layer SE Ranking keyword and ranking data on top of your Search Console queries, so every page gets a volume, a position, and an intent. We run SE Visible to see where you stand in AI search. We check your Google Business Profile against your top competitor’s.
- The technical and backlink audits. We run a full technical audit of your site through SE Ranking, which flags crawl, indexing, schema, metadata, and internal link issues and explains how to fix each one, plus a backlink audit. We send you both reports. They’re yours to keep whether or not we work together.
- The screen share. This is the part most agencies replace with a PDF. A strategist gets on a call, shares the screen, and walks you through what we found in plain language: the bigger picture of what’s going on, not a list of warnings. You see your own numbers, not a score.
- The low-hanging-fruit list. Pages at positions 11 to 30 with real volume, ranked by how much they could move and how fast. This is usually the most exciting ten minutes of the call.
- The written summary. After the call you get a detailed summary of the findings and recommendations, with the SE Ranking technical audit attached.
- The strategy conversation. What we’d do first, what we’d do over six months, and what we wouldn’t bother with. If we’re not the right fit, we’ll say so and point you to someone who is.
If we do end up working together, this first look is just the start. Onboarding includes a full, in-depth audit of the website and everything connected to it, because you can’t build a six-month roadmap on a 45-minute call. That deeper audit now runs on microSEO, our own AI SEO and GEO operating system, created by my business partner Daniel Burns and me. It powers much of what we do at Boulder SEO Marketing and at our sister company, Enterprise GEO, which we founded for mid-sized and enterprise businesses whose needs go well beyond local search. If that describes you, that site is the better place to start.
One thing we want to be clear about, because owners ask: the audit call is human-led. You’re not handed off to a platform. Many of the strategists and specialists on our team have ten or more years in this work, and it still takes a person to make sense of the data and decide what matters for your business. The tools, AI included, make us faster. They don’t replace the judgment.
If that sounds like what you’ve been looking for, request your free screen-share review here. Depending on what we find, we may bring a senior digital strategist or our Google Business Profile specialist onto the call.
What does an SEO audit cost?
For a local service business, an SEO audit shouldn’t cost anything. These websites are usually small, a few dozen pages at most, and an experienced strategist can audit one in anywhere from twenty minutes to a few hours. Automated tools give you a free score in seconds, and the score is worth about what you paid for it. Many agencies charge for a standalone audit, and some of those audits are excellent. Ours is free: we point out what we find on the call, send you a detailed summary of findings and recommendations afterward, and attach the technical audit from SE Ranking. The audit is how we start every conversation and how we find out whether we’re a good fit for each other. We’d rather show you what’s going on than send you an invoice for a document.
What costs money is the work that comes after. If you want to know what ongoing local SEO and GEO actually runs, we published a full guide to SEO pricing models and what the work costs, and our own packages are listed on our pricing page. Figures vary a lot by market and by what’s included, so read the fine print on any quote.
Can you do an SEO audit yourself?
You can do a useful first-pass SEO audit yourself in about twenty minutes, and we’d encourage every owner to try it before talking to anyone. Here is how.
Start with the indexing check. Go to Google and type site:yourdomain.com (with your actual domain). If Google shows your pages, you’re indexed. If it shows nothing, or only a handful of pages when you have dozens, stop here. That’s your first and biggest problem.
Next, open Google Search Console if you have it. Look at the Pages report for anything marked “not indexed,” then look at the Queries report sorted by impressions. Find the searches where you’re getting shown but not clicked, and the ones sitting between positions 11 and 30. Write those down. That’s your low-hanging fruit.
Then search like a customer. Open a private or incognito window and log out of Google, because you want the results a stranger sees, not ones tuned to your own history. Search your main service plus your city. Note who’s in the map pack and who’s in the first five blue links. Then ask ChatGPT, logged out, the same question: “Who is the best [your service] in [your city]?” If a competitor comes up and you don’t, you now know what an AI visibility audit would tell you.
Finally, open your Google Business Profile next to your strongest competitor’s. Compare categories, review count, photos, and how recently each of you posted. The gaps are usually obvious once they’re side by side.
If you want real ranking and AI visibility data for this, SE Ranking offers a free 30-day trial through this link. Full disclosure, so there’s no confusion: I don’t earn anything when you sign up, and neither does BSM. I teach in the University of Strasbourg’s TCLoc master’s program, and SE Ranking gives my students and our team free access to the tool, so I like to return the favor. It’s simply the tool we use every day to see how a site ranks in Google and in AI Overviews.
What to do after an SEO audit
After an SEO audit, the order you fix things in matters more than how many things you fix. Most audits hand you fifty items. Maybe five of them move the needle this quarter.
Fix indexing first. If Google can’t see a page, nothing else you do to it counts. Then fix the Google Business Profile, because map pack improvements tend to show up fastest. Then take the pages closest to page one and sharpen them: better titles, a direct answer at the top, real proof, the right internal links. Only then start creating new content, and when you do, build one strong page per topic instead of a pile of thin ones. There’s a misconception that more content is better. Today, less is more.
Be honest with yourself about timelines. Quick wins on the Google Business Profile and on pages already near page one often show up in the first month or two. The bigger results compound over 12 to 18 months, and the businesses that win are the ones that keep going through months two, three, and four, when it feels like nothing is happening. One of our landscaping clients, Phase One Landscapes, now sees new articles typically start appearing in AI Overviews about a week after publishing, for the exact searches their customers use. That didn’t happen in week one of the engagement. It happened because the foundation was fixed first.
Do you need an SEO audit?
You need an SEO audit if you answer no to two or more of these.
When you search your main service and your city in a private window, are you in the map pack? Are you on page one of the blue links? When you ask ChatGPT or Gemini who to hire for what you do in your area, does it name you? Do you know, from your own data, how many leads your website produced last month? Has anyone looked at your Search Console in the past six months? Do you know which of your pages are sitting on page two?
Two noes means something is leaking, and an audit will find it. If you answered yes to all six, you’re in better shape than most of the businesses we talk to, and you probably don’t need us.
If you want to see what the work looks like before you reach out, we’ve turned a number of client stories into published case studies: landscapers, HVAC companies, roofers, fencing companies, garage door companies, dive shops, dental and LASIK practices, machine shops, and more. Pick the one closest to your business and read what changed.
We’re not a good fit for everyone, and we’re a great fit for many. We work with local service businesses, one to twenty locations, mostly in Colorado and across the US, who want the phone to ring and are willing to give the work six months. If that’s you, get in touch for your free screen-share review. We’ll look at your website, your Search Console, and your SE Ranking and SE Visible data together, show you exactly where you stand, and tell you what we’d fix first.
When your customers ask Google or AI who to hire, it recommends someone. Right now that might be your competitor. It’s not about rankings. It’s about whether your phone rings.
SEO audit questions we hear on first calls
What is included in an SEO audit?
An SEO audit includes a technical review (indexing, crawlability, site structure, schema), a content and on-page review (titles, headings, whether pages answer real searches), an off-page review (links, mentions, brand consistency), a Google Business Profile review, and an AI search visibility check. The useful output is a prioritized fix list, not a score.
What is in an SEO audit report?
A good SEO audit report has three parts: what’s broken and must be fixed first, which pages are closest to page one and what would move them, and what to build next. If a report is mostly automated warnings with no priorities, it’s a tool export, not an audit.
How long does an SEO audit take?
A first-pass SEO audit takes a few days once we have Search Console access, and the screen-share call runs about 30 to 45 minutes. A full technical audit and cleanup on a larger site can take two to four weeks and is part of the first month of an engagement.
How often should you audit a website for SEO?
Audit a website for SEO at least once a year, and any time traffic drops, you launch a new site, you change agencies, or Google announces a core update. We re-audit every client site at the six-month restrategy.
Is an SEO audit the same as an SEO strategy?
No. The audit is the diagnosis; the strategy is the treatment plan. An audit tells you your service page is at position 14. The strategy decides whether to improve that page, build a location page instead, or fix the Google Business Profile first, and in what order.
Does an SEO audit cover AI search like ChatGPT and AI Overviews?
A modern SEO audit should, and most still don’t. An AI visibility audit checks whether ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Google’s AI Overviews and AI Mode mention or recommend your business, and why or why not. Google’s own guidance says optimizing for its AI features is still SEO, so the fixes overlap heavily with the classic audit.
What’s the difference between a free SEO audit tool and a real audit?
A free SEO audit tool scans your page against a checklist and gives you a score. A real audit reads your actual Search Console data, compares you to competitors, checks your Google Business Profile and AI visibility, and tells you what to fix first. The tool takes a minute. The audit takes a conversation.
This guide was originally published on March 29, 2023, and was fully rewritten and updated.